Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most significant purchases of your life. It’s more than just a piece of jewelry—it's a symbol of your love story, your personal style, and your future together. While the classic round diamond solitaire remains a timeless favorite, other cuts like the marquise are making a fashionable comeback, especially when set in yellow or white gold.
But before you commit to a marquise gold engagement ring, it’s important to understand all the pros—and the potential cons. What may seem like a glamorous, unique choice could come with design challenges, durability concerns, and maintenance issues that aren’t immediately obvious.
In this guide, we’ll explore why you should think twice before choosing a marquise gold engagement ring—and what to consider if this shape is still calling your name.
What Is a Marquise Cut Engagement Ring?
The marquise cut, also known as the navette cut, is an elongated, oval-shaped diamond with pointed ends. It was reportedly commissioned by King Louis XV of France in the 18th century to resemble the lips of his mistress, the Marquise de Pompadour.
This shape is unmistakably regal and vintage-inspired, with a flattering, elongated form that can make fingers appear longer and slimmer. When set in gold, especially yellow or rose gold, the marquise cut evokes a sense of romance and old-world charm.
However, behind its beauty are a few hidden considerations that may not make it the ideal choice for everyone.
1. Fragile Tips Make It Vulnerable to Damage
One of the biggest drawbacks of the marquise cut is its sharp, pointed ends, which are the most vulnerable parts of the stone. These tips are prone to:
-
Chipping
-
Cracking
-
Breaking under impact
Even with protective prong settings like V-shaped claws, the tips remain a weak spot. If you're someone who leads an active lifestyle or wears your ring daily (as most people do), these points are more likely to snag on fabric, furniture, or get bumped.
💡 Tip:
If you still want a marquise, ensure the jeweler uses double prongs or V-prongs on each end for protection.
2. Visible Bow-Tie Effect in the Center
Most elongated diamond cuts, including the marquise, display a phenomenon called the bow-tie effect. This refers to a dark, bow-tie-shaped shadow in the center of the stone that appears due to how light reflects (or doesn't reflect) off certain facets.
While all marquise stones have some level of bow-tie, poorly cut stones can show a very prominent shadow, making the center of the diamond look dull and lifeless.
This flaw isn’t always visible in online listings or under jewelry store lighting. It often becomes noticeable in natural daylight or after regular wear.
💡 Tip:
Always view a marquise diamond in multiple lighting conditions before buying, and prioritize excellent or ideal cut grades to minimize the bow-tie.
3. Can Appear Smaller Than Other Cuts
Despite its length, marquise diamonds often look smaller than round or oval diamonds of the same carat weight. That’s because much of the carat weight is distributed along its length rather than its width or depth, creating the illusion of a thinner, more slender stone.
If you're paying premium prices for a 1-carat marquise, you may be disappointed when it doesn’t deliver the same visual impact as a 1-carat round.
In yellow or rose gold settings, which can already make stones appear slightly warmer and less brilliant, this size illusion can be amplified.
4. Notoriously Difficult to Set Symmetrically
One of the biggest challenges with marquise engagement rings is getting the setting perfectly symmetrical. Because of the unique shape and pointed ends, any slight misalignment is immediately noticeable and can make the ring appear crooked or awkward on the finger.
This requires extreme precision by the jeweler, and not all mass-market jewelers are up to the task.
In gold settings—especially in bezel or vintage-style designs—this issue is even more apparent. Any slight deviation in symmetry draws attention and detracts from the overall elegance.
5. Prone to Snagging on Clothes and Hair
Due to the elongated points and typically raised setting styles, marquise engagement rings are infamous for catching on sweaters, scarves, and hair. This can cause daily annoyance and may even lead to long-term damage if the prongs loosen or break.
If you frequently wear fabrics like knitwear or lace, or if you’re hands-on in your work or hobbies (think healthcare, education, or fitness), this can be a frustrating issue.
6. Gold Settings Can Soften Over Time
Gold—especially 18k or higher purity gold—is a relatively soft metal. Over years of wear, the prongs and settings can wear down or bend, which becomes a bigger problem with delicate cuts like marquise.
This makes regular inspections and maintenance essential to avoid stone loss or damage.
While gold is beloved for its warm tone and classic look, if not alloyed for durability (such as in 14k gold), it might not offer the longevity your marquise setting needs.
7. Difficult to Pair with Wedding Bands
Because of its unique shape and often larger spread across the finger, marquise engagement rings can be tricky to match with wedding bands. Traditional straight bands may leave noticeable gaps, while contoured bands or custom fits can add to the cost and complexity.
If you’re envisioning a seamless bridal set, the marquise shape might throw a wrench in your plans unless you opt for a custom-designed set—which comes with added cost and longer lead times.
8. Trendy Now, But Not Always Timeless
The marquise cut has had its moments of popularity—especially in the 1980s and again in recent vintage-inspired trends—but it’s not always considered a timeless choice.
Unlike round, oval, or emerald cuts, which have remained consistently popular over the decades, marquise rings are seen as more stylistically niche.
If you’re planning to wear this ring for life, consider whether your tastes might change over time or whether you’re choosing the marquise shape because it’s trendy right now.
9. Resale and Upgrade Challenges
Marquise diamonds tend to have lower resale value compared to more traditional shapes like round or princess. This is due to lower demand in the secondary market and perceived difficulty in resetting or repurposing the stone.
If you anticipate wanting to upgrade your ring in the future—or if you view your ring as a potential investment—then a marquise cut may not be your best bet.
In gold settings, especially those with vintage or antique detailing, the resale appeal can be further reduced, as styles tend to be highly specific to individual tastes.
10. Color Tends to Show More in Marquise Cut
Due to the shape and shallowness of the marquise cut, color grading imperfections tend to be more visible, especially toward the pointed ends. In lower color grade stones (like J or K), a yellow tint may become noticeable.
When paired with yellow gold, this warmth might complement the metal, but it can also amplify the color, making the diamond look less brilliant and whiter than it actually is.
For buyers seeking a crisp, icy look, this could be a deal-breaker—especially when budget constraints prevent selecting higher color grade stones (D-F).
Alternatives to Consider
If you love the elongated elegance of a marquise ring but are hesitant because of the drawbacks, consider these alternatives:
✅ Oval Cut
-
Similar elongated shape
-
Softer curves = less prone to chipping
-
Still very flattering on fingers
✅ Pear Cut
-
Unique shape with one pointed end
-
Slightly less prone to damage than marquise
-
Can still offer a vintage vibe
✅ Emerald Cut
-
Sleek, elegant, and timeless
-
No points to chip or catch
-
Lower sparkle but more clean and architectural
✅ Radiant Cut
-
Combines sparkle with elongated shape
-
No sharp points
-
Great finger coverage
When Is a Marquise Gold Ring Still a Great Choice?
Despite its challenges, a marquise gold engagement ring can still be a stunning, meaningful, and stylish choice for the right person. Here’s when it works best:
-
You value unique, vintage aesthetics
-
You’re careful with your hands and willing to maintain your ring regularly
-
You plan to have a custom setting made for symmetry and protection
-
You don’t mind standing out or bucking trends
The key is informed decision-making and working with a reputable jeweler who can guide you on cut quality, setting durability, and best practices for long-term care.
Final Thoughts: Should You Choose a Marquise Gold Engagement Ring?
The marquise cut is undeniably beautiful, with a rich history and distinctive look that sets it apart from other diamond shapes. But it’s not without its pitfalls.
From durability issues and maintenance needs to symmetry problems and resale concerns, there are many reasons to think twice before committing to a marquise gold engagement ring.
Still, if your heart is set on the marquise shape and you're aware of the potential challenges, it can absolutely be the right ring for you—with the right craftsmanship and care.
Remember, your engagement ring should reflect your personality, lifestyle, and values. Choose what makes you feel confident, beautiful, and cherished every day.